Technological/Cultural Determinism POST #2
When Slack and Wise began discussing technological determinism in Chapter 3 I decided that their points were so well put and true that I would put my foot down and declare myself a technological determinist. "Of course technology forces effects and changes in culture", I thought. After all, my iPod (which seems to be the hott [two t's] example to use in class) has completely changed the way I think about and listen to music. Before the iPod was invented I can't remember any cultural forces causing me to desperately desire a small device for holding and playing 1000 mp3s. Even much earlier in American history we can see how industrial technologies had incredible effects on the economy and workforce, the success of the motor car caused the expansion of cities across the United States, and the television changed the way people gather information and the way the economy worked (through billions of dollars in advertising). Hell, even PLATO was a technological determinist in that he believed learning to write would negatively effect the memory of his people. And let's face it, Plato was a smart dude.
But wait, it all comes back to the old "guns don't kill people, people kill people" debate. As I began to read the following section about cultural determinism I immediately began to sway in that direction too. I just couldn't make up my mind. Perhaps culture's shift towards more convenient music technology forced the invention of the iPod and thus my desperate need for one in the fall of 2004 (I got it on Christmas '04 and have been swooning over it ever since). Especially in the gun debate, Slack and Wise are quick to point out that the technology can't be left off the hook entirely. Of course people ultimately decide to pull the trigger when an intentional shooting takes place, but the gun does "help" a little bit. We can even go back to my previous examples and see how they might be construed as cultural determinism rather than technological determinism. Our downtrodden economy and sweatshop environment for workers made it essential for industrial technologies. As cities grew outside the realm of public transportation, the car sounded more and more like a great idea to mass produce. And Plato? Well look how his prediction turned out. (I never liked him anyway)
I guess what I'm getting at is that it wouldn't really make sense to consider yourself a culturally or technologically deterministic person because both have their levels of truth to them and both are important concepts to grasp within the realm of culture and technology. At times I believe culture can determine the next big technology which is then invented, introduced to the market, becomes autonomous in its effects on consumers, and then causes cultural changes that hadn't been expected. In this regard, both views would be valid.
I'm still a little torn at this point, but maybe that's a good thing.
But wait, it all comes back to the old "guns don't kill people, people kill people" debate. As I began to read the following section about cultural determinism I immediately began to sway in that direction too. I just couldn't make up my mind. Perhaps culture's shift towards more convenient music technology forced the invention of the iPod and thus my desperate need for one in the fall of 2004 (I got it on Christmas '04 and have been swooning over it ever since). Especially in the gun debate, Slack and Wise are quick to point out that the technology can't be left off the hook entirely. Of course people ultimately decide to pull the trigger when an intentional shooting takes place, but the gun does "help" a little bit. We can even go back to my previous examples and see how they might be construed as cultural determinism rather than technological determinism. Our downtrodden economy and sweatshop environment for workers made it essential for industrial technologies. As cities grew outside the realm of public transportation, the car sounded more and more like a great idea to mass produce. And Plato? Well look how his prediction turned out. (I never liked him anyway)
I guess what I'm getting at is that it wouldn't really make sense to consider yourself a culturally or technologically deterministic person because both have their levels of truth to them and both are important concepts to grasp within the realm of culture and technology. At times I believe culture can determine the next big technology which is then invented, introduced to the market, becomes autonomous in its effects on consumers, and then causes cultural changes that hadn't been expected. In this regard, both views would be valid.
I'm still a little torn at this point, but maybe that's a good thing.


1 Comments:
Tim, I'm really enjoying reading your blog so far...you do a solid job of digging into the central themes of the readings and applying them to concrete situations in your own life.
You say you wanted an ipod and got it in fall'04. did you want it for cultural or technological reasons? Dr.W.
Post a Comment
<< Home