Wednesday, January 25, 2006

Media, Culture, and Technology - POST #1

The introduction to Slack and Wise's book Culture and Technology does well to make sure that the reader understands the inherent differences between the phrases "culture and technology" and "technological culture." This distinction seems important to note because while culture is certainly influenced largely by technologies, culture is ultimately too complex a topic to speak about it solely in terms of technology. There does exist, however, the phrase culture of technology that explores the idea that technology creates a culture of it's own.

Before getting in to chapter 1 I had hoped the book would cover the theoretical differences between progress as measured my sheer amounts of new technologies versus whether or not these same technologies really make life easier for every person in the United States. So to begin I suppose one could say that my definition of "progress" was very specific and possibly flawed to begin with. Luckily Chapter 1 lays out for the reader several ideas of what progress might be defined as, one of which is the very idealistic (American?) notion that progress is anything that leads toward something better and eventually towards a Eutopia, or "the good life." While I can definitely see how this idea of a Eutopia could be the reason we strive towards progress, I tend to be more cynical in believing that technology, especially very modern and recent technology, has not really done much in the way of reaching this good life that people are looking for. In fact, the book also mentions how in some views 50% or more homes having a computer might be progress, or how a decline in mortality rates might denote progress, and even how if the internet has more traffic then surely progress is being made. In reality, though, if some American "Eutopia" really is the ultimate goal of progress, then these 3 examples are erroneous because in my opinion they are only signs that some company somewhere has made a financial gain while millions of Americans experience a widening of the technological gap. In other words, while my iPod is definitely something I wouldn't give up for the World, there are still a lot of people that not only wouldn't dream of owning an iPod, they are probably light years from having a word processor. (Excuse me if that sounded extreme and/or offensive, I just realized that came out the wrong way).

Another idea that treads a similar path was the idea that "humans are ultimately considered far less efficient" than machines. One of the paragraphs dealt with the story of a woman who had worked for 20 years as a legal secretary only to lose her job to a computer that made being a legal secretary far easier than her own knowledge of the job seemed to entail. The story was sad but I think a bit typical of the way machines have changed human lives in the past few centuries. I can understand why this occurs. Often times, as the book mentions, the same people displaced by machines eventually benefit from the convenience and products that the machines are able to produce, so they purchase the goods which in turn sparks the economy and thus leads to some other type of progress which brings us closer to Eutopia. Sounds easy, I suppose. But then I remembered something else I read. "Humans require greater and less-predictable energy input in the form of food, rest, entertainment, and so on.." This was something that perplexed me because it would seem that we are often being penalized as humans for being complex creatures who can think and interact. It would seem to me that we should embrace this concept, because what it means to be human is ultimately the driving force in the creation of society and technology. But again, I see why machines are necessary and hopefully the rest of this book will help me to be less torn on whether or not I am a fan of technology and its affect on people in the grand scheme of things.

Sounded great when I thought it up. Hope you understood it though.

Sunday, January 22, 2006

Welcome

This is where I'm going to write very poignant information about culture and technology at some future point in time.