Thursday, January 03, 2008
Wednesday, April 05, 2006
Chapter 6 - It's About Privacy and Stuff, Right?
A very interesting chapter and one that I absolutely cannot wait to discuss in class. I have a feeling the debate is going to be rather heated and opinionated, and hilarity will most definitely ensue.
Castells begins by laying out the fact that the internet simply cannot be censored due to our wonderful Free Speech amendment (#1 if I'm not mistaken). He then goes into some of the reasons why this poses a problem to normal internet users like us. There are terrorist organizations linking up and child pornography rings plaguing the scape of the internet, and legislation is not able to abolish them quick enough. Luckily for us some websites that deal with taboo issues like pornography legally are using the newest forms of security to keep the wrong eyes from accessing its content. These include passwords, cookies, and other authentication procedures that are expanding in ability on a yearly basis.
Castells then goes on to show how some similar technologies to those being used to keep people OUT of websites is being used in other ways in an attempt to gather information about you, the casual web browser, during your browsing. Yes, surveillance has taken over the internet and you are technically being watched while you surf the net. Companies are recording your every click as a way to better serve their own image and...make more money.
One key quote from page 80/81:
Some scary stuff?
I think one of the most interesting aspects of the privacy debate is the fact that the internet is largely free of policing on a Global scale. There is very little that can be done or has been done through legislation regarding the internet. As long as a website is written in a language people can understand, anyone in the world who has access to the web can access the site and be influenced by it. This of course is not limited to the fact that some things that are legal in other countries (drugs?) are not legal in the US. What's to stop the mass transactions of these types of products via the internet over the internet?
Castells begins by laying out the fact that the internet simply cannot be censored due to our wonderful Free Speech amendment (#1 if I'm not mistaken). He then goes into some of the reasons why this poses a problem to normal internet users like us. There are terrorist organizations linking up and child pornography rings plaguing the scape of the internet, and legislation is not able to abolish them quick enough. Luckily for us some websites that deal with taboo issues like pornography legally are using the newest forms of security to keep the wrong eyes from accessing its content. These include passwords, cookies, and other authentication procedures that are expanding in ability on a yearly basis.
Castells then goes on to show how some similar technologies to those being used to keep people OUT of websites is being used in other ways in an attempt to gather information about you, the casual web browser, during your browsing. Yes, surveillance has taken over the internet and you are technically being watched while you surf the net. Companies are recording your every click as a way to better serve their own image and...make more money.
One key quote from page 80/81:
It is not Big Brother, but a multitude of little sisters, agencies of surveillance and processing of information that record our behavior for ever, as databases surround us throughout our life -- soon starting with out DNA and personal features...the transparency of our lives will decisively shape our atitudes. No one has been able to live in a transparent society...We may have no liberty, and no place to hide.
Some scary stuff?
I think one of the most interesting aspects of the privacy debate is the fact that the internet is largely free of policing on a Global scale. There is very little that can be done or has been done through legislation regarding the internet. As long as a website is written in a language people can understand, anyone in the world who has access to the web can access the site and be influenced by it. This of course is not limited to the fact that some things that are legal in other countries (drugs?) are not legal in the US. What's to stop the mass transactions of these types of products via the internet over the internet?
Wednesday, March 29, 2006
Chapter 9 - The Digital Divide
Whoa, Manuel Castells, slow down with the facts, buddy. My brain can only handle so much af that stuff at this point in your book.
What I believe we have here with Castells interpretation of the Digital Divide is a collection of facts that point out what I would otherwise have just considered obvious. Yes, of course people who are poor, living in low income housing, and working 12-15 hour days won't have the same access to the internet as you and I. It also seems obvious that those who lack access will only continue to fall behind in the competitive global economy. What I don't understand is why Castells (who seems to have a great deal of knowledge in the subject) doesn't offer any real solutions to the problem himself. Yes we should do all that we can, especially within the United States, to help those without internet access to obtain it. However, even if we were to give internet access to all of the "underprivilaged" and provide them with computers, there would still exist a large learning curve and the need for someone to teach the skills involved with aptly using the internet. Luckily, here in the United States, I believe that the government is trying harder now to provide internet access and modern computers to schools--especially elementary schools-- even in poor areas of the country. If children really are the future, then hopefully they'll learn the internet and eventually demand it and work towards obtaining it for their own daily life at home.
Overseas, however is another beast altogether. Castells mentions the UN's Human Development Report findings a lot. He seems to believe that they are infallable even. However, these findings suggest poverty in some third-world nations that is hard to even imagine by a lot of Westerners. The report, in a way, suggests that bringing internet to some of these areas would help to close the digital divide. I don't understand this. I guess I can see how the internet might be of use as a means of coming together and helping each other for a greater community good, but these people would be largely without the knowledge to operate a computer at this point. And if they're truly making $2/day, what good will the internet do? We hear about christian missionaries going to Africa on a yearly basis to help with food, other supplies, and medical treatment. Why not form some sort of internet missionary group, comprised of thousands and have them travel the world with Santa sacks full of technological gadgets and goodies, providing all the underpriviledged with computers and internet access and then showing them how to use it? Oh, and tell them to bring some freakin bread and light bulbs too, I think that would be more important, don't you?
What I believe we have here with Castells interpretation of the Digital Divide is a collection of facts that point out what I would otherwise have just considered obvious. Yes, of course people who are poor, living in low income housing, and working 12-15 hour days won't have the same access to the internet as you and I. It also seems obvious that those who lack access will only continue to fall behind in the competitive global economy. What I don't understand is why Castells (who seems to have a great deal of knowledge in the subject) doesn't offer any real solutions to the problem himself. Yes we should do all that we can, especially within the United States, to help those without internet access to obtain it. However, even if we were to give internet access to all of the "underprivilaged" and provide them with computers, there would still exist a large learning curve and the need for someone to teach the skills involved with aptly using the internet. Luckily, here in the United States, I believe that the government is trying harder now to provide internet access and modern computers to schools--especially elementary schools-- even in poor areas of the country. If children really are the future, then hopefully they'll learn the internet and eventually demand it and work towards obtaining it for their own daily life at home.
Overseas, however is another beast altogether. Castells mentions the UN's Human Development Report findings a lot. He seems to believe that they are infallable even. However, these findings suggest poverty in some third-world nations that is hard to even imagine by a lot of Westerners. The report, in a way, suggests that bringing internet to some of these areas would help to close the digital divide. I don't understand this. I guess I can see how the internet might be of use as a means of coming together and helping each other for a greater community good, but these people would be largely without the knowledge to operate a computer at this point. And if they're truly making $2/day, what good will the internet do? We hear about christian missionaries going to Africa on a yearly basis to help with food, other supplies, and medical treatment. Why not form some sort of internet missionary group, comprised of thousands and have them travel the world with Santa sacks full of technological gadgets and goodies, providing all the underpriviledged with computers and internet access and then showing them how to use it? Oh, and tell them to bring some freakin bread and light bulbs too, I think that would be more important, don't you?
Wednesday, February 15, 2006
The Internet Galaxy - Pgs 1-63
Ignoring the history of the internet's existence, I found it almost overwhelming to learn about the hakcer culture that Castells writes about in chapter 1 of The Internet Galaxy. He delves into the culture of people who became instrumental in the development of the internet as we know it on the heels of such ARPANET and other protocol projects that came out of the 50s,60s, and 70s. These people have been known as the "hackers," although to write about this culture one must first make the distinction between "hackers" and "crackers," the latter of which are the internet criminals one might hear about on the news. Real hackers are those who have communicated through networks and worked together for nothing more than recognition to write code and develop operating systems and programs. The fascinating part of this is how nobody in mainstream media or even more underground social fabrics seem to realize that such a culture of networkers exists. Even better is the sort of way in which these people work. They basically work for the love of their computer. There is a basic hierarchy of superiors and people new to the game, but for the most part hackers enjoy customs that include freedom, sharing, and the occasional praise. They create or modify a program and then allow others access to it via the internet so that they themselves can make changes. There isn't much worry about monetary forces or other outside interference, and at the end of the day it is the creativity and the will to become a sort of hacker celebrity that drives the creation of new and better networking technologies. This is fascinating because it seems to be unlike any other form of culture that we see in the United States. Usually people are vying for monetary gain or promotions, having long ago lost that American goal of simply being the best at what we do just to prove that freedom and liberty are ultimately worth fighting for.
Accordingly, the story about Linus Torvalds and his Linux OS was pretty interesting as well. Although the book doesn't really do a good enough job telling me exactly what Linux is or what it does, I find it pretty fascinating that a kid from overseas could become a pseudo-hacker celebrity, or "tribal elder," as the book puts it. It occured to me that without people like Torvalds there would not be the more maintstream version of networks that most of us have come to know and love. There would not be AIM, AOL, e-mail, and blogs? No blogs???? NOOOOOOOOOO. So I think it's great that we were able to read about this underground culture of internet-people who make our lives better simply by having interests and wanting to be creative. That is all.
Accordingly, the story about Linus Torvalds and his Linux OS was pretty interesting as well. Although the book doesn't really do a good enough job telling me exactly what Linux is or what it does, I find it pretty fascinating that a kid from overseas could become a pseudo-hacker celebrity, or "tribal elder," as the book puts it. It occured to me that without people like Torvalds there would not be the more maintstream version of networks that most of us have come to know and love. There would not be AIM, AOL, e-mail, and blogs? No blogs???? NOOOOOOOOOO. So I think it's great that we were able to read about this underground culture of internet-people who make our lives better simply by having interests and wanting to be creative. That is all.
Wednesday, February 08, 2006
POST #3 - Technology Failed in Iraq
Pardon me for neglecting to write about the main reading from Culture and Technology in this entry. The other reading from the internet had me so angry I decided I needed to vent about it in blog form. This article was a prime example of America's dependence on technology that we aren't even smart enough to be able to handle. I guess what I dislike most about the failure of technology in Iraq is that these are not the stories that are played on television news ever. As far as the Bush administration is concerned these failures never even happened, I'm sure. At one point in this article, Talbot mentions that some marines were so failed by their location technology that their way of finding enemies was just to run into them, which was the way war was conducted in 1944. Not exactly what America envisioned, right? The reason that I say America is too dependent on technology sometimes is because the article even mentions how the administration planned on replacing a large army with a swift-moving technologically advanced unit who would be able to communicate from all angles and spot enemies from very far distances. They also plan on eventually replacing heavy tanks entirely with lighter tanks able to evade enemy fire, and although high officials have acknowledged the problems they've encountered in Iraq, I'm skeptical about whether or not these problems will be worked out in timre for more people to not die.
Technologically, I guess another reason I'm mad that some of us are finding out about this from an article we had to read for class is because of some of the other advances in technology that I've read about in the past few months. One particular advancement in warfare technology is the robot that I'm sure some of you have seen that just sort of rolls around and is able to spot enemies and shoot at them with small arms and some sort of explosive devices. This sounds like something from the movies, I know. Another that I've heard of recently is a chip that has been developed that scientists plan to implant into the brains of soldiers that has a positive effect on memory. Apparently it improves long-term memory.
My point is that these are the stories more likely to be reported on in American news. They want us not to worry about a thing by having us believe that the American Army is only a few years away from creating super soldiers and having world dominating robots. In reality though, the technology we rely on now isn't even working over in Iraq. Just angers me I guess..
Technologically, I guess another reason I'm mad that some of us are finding out about this from an article we had to read for class is because of some of the other advances in technology that I've read about in the past few months. One particular advancement in warfare technology is the robot that I'm sure some of you have seen that just sort of rolls around and is able to spot enemies and shoot at them with small arms and some sort of explosive devices. This sounds like something from the movies, I know. Another that I've heard of recently is a chip that has been developed that scientists plan to implant into the brains of soldiers that has a positive effect on memory. Apparently it improves long-term memory.
My point is that these are the stories more likely to be reported on in American news. They want us not to worry about a thing by having us believe that the American Army is only a few years away from creating super soldiers and having world dominating robots. In reality though, the technology we rely on now isn't even working over in Iraq. Just angers me I guess..
Wednesday, February 01, 2006
Technological/Cultural Determinism POST #2
When Slack and Wise began discussing technological determinism in Chapter 3 I decided that their points were so well put and true that I would put my foot down and declare myself a technological determinist. "Of course technology forces effects and changes in culture", I thought. After all, my iPod (which seems to be the hott [two t's] example to use in class) has completely changed the way I think about and listen to music. Before the iPod was invented I can't remember any cultural forces causing me to desperately desire a small device for holding and playing 1000 mp3s. Even much earlier in American history we can see how industrial technologies had incredible effects on the economy and workforce, the success of the motor car caused the expansion of cities across the United States, and the television changed the way people gather information and the way the economy worked (through billions of dollars in advertising). Hell, even PLATO was a technological determinist in that he believed learning to write would negatively effect the memory of his people. And let's face it, Plato was a smart dude.
But wait, it all comes back to the old "guns don't kill people, people kill people" debate. As I began to read the following section about cultural determinism I immediately began to sway in that direction too. I just couldn't make up my mind. Perhaps culture's shift towards more convenient music technology forced the invention of the iPod and thus my desperate need for one in the fall of 2004 (I got it on Christmas '04 and have been swooning over it ever since). Especially in the gun debate, Slack and Wise are quick to point out that the technology can't be left off the hook entirely. Of course people ultimately decide to pull the trigger when an intentional shooting takes place, but the gun does "help" a little bit. We can even go back to my previous examples and see how they might be construed as cultural determinism rather than technological determinism. Our downtrodden economy and sweatshop environment for workers made it essential for industrial technologies. As cities grew outside the realm of public transportation, the car sounded more and more like a great idea to mass produce. And Plato? Well look how his prediction turned out. (I never liked him anyway)
I guess what I'm getting at is that it wouldn't really make sense to consider yourself a culturally or technologically deterministic person because both have their levels of truth to them and both are important concepts to grasp within the realm of culture and technology. At times I believe culture can determine the next big technology which is then invented, introduced to the market, becomes autonomous in its effects on consumers, and then causes cultural changes that hadn't been expected. In this regard, both views would be valid.
I'm still a little torn at this point, but maybe that's a good thing.
But wait, it all comes back to the old "guns don't kill people, people kill people" debate. As I began to read the following section about cultural determinism I immediately began to sway in that direction too. I just couldn't make up my mind. Perhaps culture's shift towards more convenient music technology forced the invention of the iPod and thus my desperate need for one in the fall of 2004 (I got it on Christmas '04 and have been swooning over it ever since). Especially in the gun debate, Slack and Wise are quick to point out that the technology can't be left off the hook entirely. Of course people ultimately decide to pull the trigger when an intentional shooting takes place, but the gun does "help" a little bit. We can even go back to my previous examples and see how they might be construed as cultural determinism rather than technological determinism. Our downtrodden economy and sweatshop environment for workers made it essential for industrial technologies. As cities grew outside the realm of public transportation, the car sounded more and more like a great idea to mass produce. And Plato? Well look how his prediction turned out. (I never liked him anyway)
I guess what I'm getting at is that it wouldn't really make sense to consider yourself a culturally or technologically deterministic person because both have their levels of truth to them and both are important concepts to grasp within the realm of culture and technology. At times I believe culture can determine the next big technology which is then invented, introduced to the market, becomes autonomous in its effects on consumers, and then causes cultural changes that hadn't been expected. In this regard, both views would be valid.
I'm still a little torn at this point, but maybe that's a good thing.
Wednesday, January 25, 2006
Media, Culture, and Technology - POST #1
The introduction to Slack and Wise's book Culture and Technology does well to make sure that the reader understands the inherent differences between the phrases "culture and technology" and "technological culture." This distinction seems important to note because while culture is certainly influenced largely by technologies, culture is ultimately too complex a topic to speak about it solely in terms of technology. There does exist, however, the phrase culture of technology that explores the idea that technology creates a culture of it's own.
Before getting in to chapter 1 I had hoped the book would cover the theoretical differences between progress as measured my sheer amounts of new technologies versus whether or not these same technologies really make life easier for every person in the United States. So to begin I suppose one could say that my definition of "progress" was very specific and possibly flawed to begin with. Luckily Chapter 1 lays out for the reader several ideas of what progress might be defined as, one of which is the very idealistic (American?) notion that progress is anything that leads toward something better and eventually towards a Eutopia, or "the good life." While I can definitely see how this idea of a Eutopia could be the reason we strive towards progress, I tend to be more cynical in believing that technology, especially very modern and recent technology, has not really done much in the way of reaching this good life that people are looking for. In fact, the book also mentions how in some views 50% or more homes having a computer might be progress, or how a decline in mortality rates might denote progress, and even how if the internet has more traffic then surely progress is being made. In reality, though, if some American "Eutopia" really is the ultimate goal of progress, then these 3 examples are erroneous because in my opinion they are only signs that some company somewhere has made a financial gain while millions of Americans experience a widening of the technological gap. In other words, while my iPod is definitely something I wouldn't give up for the World, there are still a lot of people that not only wouldn't dream of owning an iPod, they are probably light years from having a word processor. (Excuse me if that sounded extreme and/or offensive, I just realized that came out the wrong way).
Another idea that treads a similar path was the idea that "humans are ultimately considered far less efficient" than machines. One of the paragraphs dealt with the story of a woman who had worked for 20 years as a legal secretary only to lose her job to a computer that made being a legal secretary far easier than her own knowledge of the job seemed to entail. The story was sad but I think a bit typical of the way machines have changed human lives in the past few centuries. I can understand why this occurs. Often times, as the book mentions, the same people displaced by machines eventually benefit from the convenience and products that the machines are able to produce, so they purchase the goods which in turn sparks the economy and thus leads to some other type of progress which brings us closer to Eutopia. Sounds easy, I suppose. But then I remembered something else I read. "Humans require greater and less-predictable energy input in the form of food, rest, entertainment, and so on.." This was something that perplexed me because it would seem that we are often being penalized as humans for being complex creatures who can think and interact. It would seem to me that we should embrace this concept, because what it means to be human is ultimately the driving force in the creation of society and technology. But again, I see why machines are necessary and hopefully the rest of this book will help me to be less torn on whether or not I am a fan of technology and its affect on people in the grand scheme of things.
Sounded great when I thought it up. Hope you understood it though.
Before getting in to chapter 1 I had hoped the book would cover the theoretical differences between progress as measured my sheer amounts of new technologies versus whether or not these same technologies really make life easier for every person in the United States. So to begin I suppose one could say that my definition of "progress" was very specific and possibly flawed to begin with. Luckily Chapter 1 lays out for the reader several ideas of what progress might be defined as, one of which is the very idealistic (American?) notion that progress is anything that leads toward something better and eventually towards a Eutopia, or "the good life." While I can definitely see how this idea of a Eutopia could be the reason we strive towards progress, I tend to be more cynical in believing that technology, especially very modern and recent technology, has not really done much in the way of reaching this good life that people are looking for. In fact, the book also mentions how in some views 50% or more homes having a computer might be progress, or how a decline in mortality rates might denote progress, and even how if the internet has more traffic then surely progress is being made. In reality, though, if some American "Eutopia" really is the ultimate goal of progress, then these 3 examples are erroneous because in my opinion they are only signs that some company somewhere has made a financial gain while millions of Americans experience a widening of the technological gap. In other words, while my iPod is definitely something I wouldn't give up for the World, there are still a lot of people that not only wouldn't dream of owning an iPod, they are probably light years from having a word processor. (Excuse me if that sounded extreme and/or offensive, I just realized that came out the wrong way).
Another idea that treads a similar path was the idea that "humans are ultimately considered far less efficient" than machines. One of the paragraphs dealt with the story of a woman who had worked for 20 years as a legal secretary only to lose her job to a computer that made being a legal secretary far easier than her own knowledge of the job seemed to entail. The story was sad but I think a bit typical of the way machines have changed human lives in the past few centuries. I can understand why this occurs. Often times, as the book mentions, the same people displaced by machines eventually benefit from the convenience and products that the machines are able to produce, so they purchase the goods which in turn sparks the economy and thus leads to some other type of progress which brings us closer to Eutopia. Sounds easy, I suppose. But then I remembered something else I read. "Humans require greater and less-predictable energy input in the form of food, rest, entertainment, and so on.." This was something that perplexed me because it would seem that we are often being penalized as humans for being complex creatures who can think and interact. It would seem to me that we should embrace this concept, because what it means to be human is ultimately the driving force in the creation of society and technology. But again, I see why machines are necessary and hopefully the rest of this book will help me to be less torn on whether or not I am a fan of technology and its affect on people in the grand scheme of things.
Sounded great when I thought it up. Hope you understood it though.

